Reviews
SPB has released the much anticipated updated version of Mobile Shell 2.0. It's hard to say that Mobile Shell 3.0 is an update to the previous versions of this popular utility because of the dramatic changes present with 3.0. Just looking at the home page of both versions, the casual observer would think they are looking at two unique applications.
We received an advance copy of Mobile Shell 3.0 about a week ago and found it to be very feature rich and more customizable than its predecessor. You know the drill, to find out more about Mobile Shell 3.0 plus plenty of screen shots, simply follow the break.
It was tough to find a starting point for this review simply because Mobile Shell 3.0 has so much to it. It builds upon 2.x very nicely but in the process SPB ends up with almost a completely different application. The transformation reminds me of when Windows 3.1 was updated to Windows 95. You still had a Windows operating system but the look and feel was noticeably different.
Where Mobile Shell 2.x placed a tabbed plug-in on the traditional Today Screen, Mobile Shell 3.0 takes over the Today Screen. You can still access the traditional Today Screen but Mobile Shell becomes your new "home" page and that's probably a good place to start with the nuts and bolts of the review.
Mobile Shell has two home page layouts to choose between. You have the Professional Layout that is rather conservative in appearance and is almost a mirror image of Mobile Shell 2.x's "Now Screen". SPB added a second home screen layout, the Lifestyle Layout that is more casual and is highly customizable through the use of widgets.
The Professional Layout has the date/time, weather icon, messaging center, and calendar displayed. Customization of the Professional Layout is limited to a few options with the calendar display. The Professional Layout is designed to give you a snapshot of your day.
Where the Professional Layout is a single screen, the Lifestyle Layout has two pages to either side of the main screen. These side panels (swipe navigable)can hold widgets ranging from media player to contacts to application launchers. Switching between layouts is as easy as a up/down swipe or you can use the menu tab (lower right corner of the screen) to change layouts. One nice feature of the Lifestyle Layout is that you can use a larger landscape image and as you pan across the three pages, you pan the image. Below is a flow chart of the Mobile Shell 3.0 home pages.
On either home page layout, you can launch applications by tapping on the icons. The weather application can be accessed by tapping the weather icon, the agenda app by tapping the calendar display, etc. Depending on your phone, the End Key as well as the Home Key will return you to the last Home Page you viewed. If you were on a widget page of the Lifestyle Layout, that is where you will return to.
I ended up parking my AT&T Fuze on the Professional Layout to take advantage of the snapshot view it offers and, just a swipe away, built the LifeStyle Layout with widgets to send me to my more commonly used applications and contacts.
At the bottom of either home page layout you'll find a Launcher and Contact icon as well as a menu and carousel tab that sits in the left and right corner respectively.
The Launcher icon takes you to equivalent of your Programs Window in Mobile Shell 2.0. The Launcher has two layout styles as well that can be navigated between by tapping the icons at the bottom or swipe the screen.
The first layout contains customizable favorites and recently used applications. The second layout has applications sorted by category in various folders (Internet, Tools, Programs, etc.) Tap on one of the icons and you can select from various applications from that category. Unlike version 2, the programs are scrollable from top to bottom as opposed to page to page.
The Contact Icon, as you would guess, takes you to the phones contacts. By default, you are taken to the Favorite Contacts page. This is the "speed dial" icons/avatars that take you directly to a specific contact where you can choose to dial one of the numbers, send SMS messages or email the contact.
The other icons at the bottom of this window include your call log and full contact listing. The full contact listing can be navigated by scrolling up/down the list or by dialing the first five letters of the contacts name. This will narrow the field, making finding the desired contact easier. I would have liked to have seen alphabetical tabs on this screen but the keypad search works.
The Menu Tab (located at the bottom right) will pull up the menu options for each screen. Instead of a "pop-up" menu for your options, you have a "pop-up" window with icons representing the various options. The options will vary from screen to screen.
I had my hands on the review copy for a few days before the documentation caught up with me so learning Mobile Shell 3.0 was somewhat of an adventure into the unknown. Every finger swipe revealed a new window or feature that it wouldn't have surprised me if I stumbled upon a kitchen sink. And it all starts with the Carousel Tab.
The Carousel tab (to the bottom left) pulls up a carousel view of the various SPB pages as well as the home pages and pages accessible via the home page icons (contacts and launcher). Essentially it is a one stop shop for the various panels/windows of Mobile Shell 3.0. The carousel is touch navigable and once you find your page, tap on it for it to go full screen.
You can also switch to a tile/panel view. This view reminds me of the panels Sony uses on the Xperia. One can only hope that SPB opens Mobile Shell up for additional panels just as Sony did with the Xperia.
The Weather panel can be set to a specific city and displays the current conditions and four day forecast. The city selection includes a strong representation of U.S. and International locations. I would be shocked if someone couldn't find a location close to their house.
The Agenda Page will display up to four weeks of appointments as well as a calendar of that period. You can customize the agenda appearance to show open dates as well. The calendar view is collapsible and, as with most of the windows in Mobile Shell 3.0, the agenda is touch navigable.
The Phone Profile is where you can set the ringer volume, system sounds volume, the ring tone and type. The Time panel has your alarm function as well as displays for two additional time zones/cities.
The Contact Carousel panel is a quick way to customize your favorite contacts (those you create widgets of). Here you have a touch navigable carousel which will allow you to set ring tones for an individual contact and manage the contact picture.
One of the many new features to Mobile Shell 3.0 is the ability to integrate Facebook Profile pictures to your contacts. You have the ability to choose a camera from a file or take one with the camera but now if your contact is a Facebook friend, you can import one of their Facebook portrait pictures.
The one thing that was nice about Mobile Shell 2.0 is the amount of settings you could tweak. The settings pages were all under one roof, a one-stop shop if you will.
With 3.0, settings are scattered about a little more. Instead of having the core settings tabbed and under one roof, they are more categorized under separate icons. Additionally, as mentioned, each page will have some menu options to allow for customization. Color themes are now a separate application and not located under the Mobile Shell settings window.
There are two settings that jumped off the screen at me. The "Override Start" option sends you to the Launcher window when you tap the "Start" menu of Windows Mobile on a Home Page. This option appears to only affect the Home Pages because the drop down "Start Menu" continues to appear with the interior pages.
You also have a 3D accelerator option but if your phone has not been tested, you get a nice warning saying that using the accelerator may cause performance issues. On the Fuze, a phone that hasn't been tested, I get the warning but didn't notice any performance changes. In using the accelerator or override start options, a soft reset is required for the system to accept the changes.
It's somewhat unfair to compare Mobile Shell 3.0 to Mobile Shell 2.x because they are so vastly different. Mobile Shell 2.x really dealt with life beyond the Today Screen while Mobile Shell 3.0 steps to the forefront. I'm a big fan of Mobile Shell 2.0 and quickly becoming a big fan of Mobile Shell 3.0. There were a few hiccups along the way but nothing terminal. For the most part, Mobile Shell 3.0 was stable and ran smoothly save two experiences. Touch navigation was smooth and responsive as well.
For some reason during my initial installation of Mobile Shell 3.0 I lost the ability to close programs by tapping the "x" and lost the drop down Task Manager icon that sits on the upper right corner of the screen. After uninstalling Mobile Shell 3.0, soft resetting and re-installing Mobile Shell 3.0 everything functioned properly with regards to closing programs.
Screen rotation was noticeably slower with Mobile Shell 3.0. In testing it on the AT&T Fuze, it took approximately four seconds for the screen to rotate when I extended the keyboard or turned the Fuze horizontally.
Another glitch in screen rotation is that with the Lifestyle Layout, the widgets have a tendency to get bunched up with the horizontal view because they can't adjust to the narrower view. I found that the smaller widgets and contact sizes work better but if you put a larger widget (e.g. calendar) it has a hard time adjusting to the rotated layout. This problem was not present with the Professional Layout and while it can be annoying, I don't think it's a deal breaker.
I really liked the widgets and the ease in which they are created and customized (you can change the size, position, and add labeling to most widgets) but customization is not universal. For example, while you can create a widget for individual email accounts you can't label them. Sorta defeats the purpose of having separate widgets.
Another short coming with the widgets is that can't create a widget for your Outlook email. You can choose a widget for all incoming messages that will cover email, SMS, and missed calls but it would be nice to separate all your email accounts much like the traditional Today Screen does.
SPB points out in their release documentation that Mobile Shell 2.x was a tremendous success and it was challenging to design 3.0 since customer expectations are quite high. Just as Microsoft took the windows concept of 3.1 and developed a successful update in Windows 95, I think SPB has done the same with Mobile Shell 3.0. SPB has taken the concept and functionality of Mobile Shell 2.0 and added a tremendous amount of functionality to it. Additionally, SPB developed Mobile Shell 3.0 to be compatible with Windows Mobile 6.5 so when the WM 6.5 phones becomes available, Mobile Shell 3.0 should still compliment Windows Mobile without any (expected?)conflicts.
We have always considered the Mobile Shell line-up as a "must have" application for Windows Mobile and version 3.0 isn't any different. If you are a loyal Mobile Shell 2.0 user, version 3.0 does have a fifteen day trial period. It's definitely worth a look but give the trial version a few days to sink in. There is so much to Mobile Shell 3.0 that it can be a little overwhelming and may take a day or so before you can make a proper evaluation. It does have a few issues but nothing I think will send you screaming back to the checkout counter for a refund.
Mobile Shell 2.x or 3.0? I don't think you can loose either way but it's hard to ignore the features and customization that 3.0 offers.
Comments
good review and spot on!
i got the unofficial version and love it! :)
had it since last week and i cannot live without it at this point.
i had ms2 with a cool theme and it beat out ALL phones in terms of appearance.
now ms3 beats them in terms of appearance, useability, and overall "wow thats cool" from my iphone and gphone competitors :)
Tried the leaked and official versions and I still dont see whats so great about it. There are a few "disconnect" issues - like the phone dialer looking completely different to the SPB menus and the widget home screen background only visible on that screen. It also seems to take too many taps to get to your programs compared to just hitting the start menu (in 6.5). You cant edit the spb call log and you dial immediately you tap on a number listed instead of getting a menu to save or text. Still seems to ignore 3rd party PIM apps if you have them set as your default PIM manager. WM 6.5 is more functional with the sliding panels. Mobile Shell just doesnt do it for me.
several things wrong here. If the caller is not in your contacts log it will call but otherwise it goes to a full contract presentation with choice of call, email, sms, etc. that seems pretty smart to me.
secondly it does not take more taps, yo can confgure your homescreen with all kinds of widgets. you also can choose to go right to your start menu so it never has to take any more taps even from there.
It is i powerful but very customizable so it can take less taps. read the forums at spc club and manual. It certainly puts 6.5 to shame in a lot of ways.
well!
if only everyone had 6.5! (joke)
So far, I'm not a fan...too much stuff, too many options, much harder to do some basic things (like launch an app).
I'm gonna play around more with it but I think they're trying too hard with this one (that and it just seems like you need a big screen to really appreciate it).
Facebook looked like it was going to work, let me log in then show some of my facebook friends pictures, but when tried to put pic on my phone contact, It kept saying could not connect to facebook. Anyone else have this work or not work?
yeah i had that too, after few minutes i figured out what to do.
Open pocket IE, log into m.facebook.com, then minimize pocket IE and go to contacts in Mobile shell to add pics from Facebook, it should now connect and ask you if you would like to allow Mobile Shell to get picks from facebook. Choose the picks.
Let me know if it worked for you.
- s3ntrax
It feels like overkill in some areas, but some great advancements in others (kinetic scrolling and contacts management most notably.)
It's definitely not as beginner friendly as the previous versions which may limit its appeal some in the face of other options from HTC and with the upcoming WM6.5 UI.
Did the Facebook feature not work for anybody else?
the e-mail accounts can be split in the release version!
Yes but they cant be named so you dont know which is which.
you can name them by making a widget. the widgets are hugely powerful
I think it seems overwhelming or overkill if you don't read up and spend 15 minutes learning to limit and control the screens. After that you realize you have a lot of control and ability to customize, and it can be be made less busy and more ergonometric than Mobile Shell 2.0
I was very disappointed and restored my phone back to MS 2 within the hour. The main problem for me was they gutted the functionality of the program launcher. Of the eight folders, only one is configurable.
My phone has both Opera and Internet Explorer. In the Internet folder, the favorites and history icons only do Opera. There was no access to Internet Explorer's favorites and history. There was no way to add additional internet programs like Remote Desktop Client or Live Search or Google Earth.
Want to use a different picture viewer? To bad. You can't add one to the Multimedia tab.
Want to program the left and right soft buttons on the Today screen to specific panels of the GUI? To bad, they removed that feature too.
And after all this time, they still haven't added any support for the task list.
Hopefully 3.1 will make this new one usable. There's an old saying in the industry: never use version x.0 of anything. SPB has failed to be ane exception to that adage.
Consider reading various threads. Modaco and Ppcgeeks have some.
Tested 3.0 the last few days but still not a fan of SPB mobile shell. As always, it seems like there are too many taps to get to certain places. Transition animations and kinetic scrolling is "okay" coming from PointUI 2 (smoother imo). I do like the ability to customize the lifestyle layout. Very simple with movable widgets.
The carousel seems tedious and the kinetics a little too sensitive. I don't see myself ever using it to scroll contacts or screen/panels. The tile view is a bit easier to navigate but I would rather tap 1 button and go straight to that screen rather than open up the tiles and scan through all the panels.
All in all, it's a solid product, but personally I'd choose PointUI 2 or TF3D over it.
Mobile shell 2.0 also had two Now screen layouts, "professional" and "classic". Professional looks like the new professional layout, while classic looks like the new "lifestyle" layout. I guess the main difference with 3.0 is the addition of widgets.
Although I haven't tried it yet, from what I can tell by the screenshots and descriptions, your analogy of "Windows 3.1 to Windows 95" is really pushing it a bit far. Most of the functionality described here is present in Mobile Shell 2.0, with a few improvements. Even the visual style is very similar.
Great review.
I think Mobile shell is the best shell for Windows Mobile.
I love the launcher screen, the contacts, and the new calendar screen.
But the best thing for me is the fact that the application is running sssssooooooo fast! It's amazing!
I don't like the kinetic scroll (I prefer the paging mechanism in version 2, and I'm sure I'm the only one thinking like that...)
And I actually didn't like so much the carousel view. It's strange.
Oh, and one more thing is missing - integration with outlook tasks.
My full report can be found in here.
Really? No one noticed that it takes 6 more MBs of ram in this version?
I bought a new phone just because of it! :D
I was tired of the crashes happening on my Eten x500+ when there were less than 20MB or ram, and this v3 completely blew that away, and left me with 16mb free megs after a soft reset instead of the usual 22 with the v2
I wasn't blown away at first, but the more time I spend with it, the more I like it. The 'Lifestyle' screen can be customized to the point of making the Professional screen (and even most of the other various launchers) unnecessary.
The things I've been most impressed with:
1) The speed on my older Vogue. Just as fast (if not faster) than V2. While I'm jealous of the specs on newer devices, I'm cheap and love the tiny size of this things so this may give me enough life with it to ride it out to WM7 (or at least until WM6.5 builds integrate Zune player functionality)
2) The kinetic scrolling is superb. Some people claim they don't want a fast scroll but give that to me any day IMO.
3) The appointment/calendar integration is outstanding. I have gobs of meetings and have already found this to be an exceptionally useful way to quickly scan through upcoming appointments and availability when discussing future meetings.
4) The contacts management and quick dials (while already good in V2) are that much stronger here and the Facebook integration is a great touch.
or my needs Spb Pocket+ and SpbMobileShell 2,15 does much much better. For example, it allows Agenda One to be my default pim management and integrates much better with other Spb products like Spb Diary which displays all my pim info in one of the pocket+ tabs, this includes hand written notes from VSNotepad and it all opens up in macro windows right from the today screen meaning less clicks. Spb time is not part of the integration, nor is Spb Insight in this new version. While this looks pretty it really does almost nothing in the way of making the device useful unless Spb Mobile Shell is all you have on your device in the way of apps. With my setup, I have 6 tabs on my today screen from mobile shell that displays weather, photo contacts, connectiion manager, resco today plus, spb time, and spb backup. Next I have Spb Insight scrolling through all the latest rss feeds from Pocketnow and then I have 6 tabs for Pocketplus which one is dedicated to Spb Diary. This all means that I can get to any of my 100 apps or my pim info in 3 clicks or less, can anybody say they can do that with the new Mobile Shell that doesnt even allow you to create new menus for the apps you have and doesnt allow you to place apps in the menus they supply, like internet I would like to place my browsers (Opera, Netfront, Iris, Skyfire) all of which I like to use.
ALL I AM SAYING IS THE CONS OF NO INTEGRATION WITH 3RD PARTY APPS, EVEN THE ONES FROM THE SAME DEVELOPER, IS A SHAME FOR A OTHERWISE GREAT LOOKING APP.
I was able to add an Outlook widget for outlook email only on the lifestyle. Click on add widget-on incoming Items click on email. The Activesync is my Outlook Exchange account only. I then set a separate widget and chose my other account, so now each one is separate. I would like to have only my Activesync Outlook on the Proffesional tab, but it's not that big of a deal to me.
Thanks for the tip. I was focusing in so much on my POP accounts that I overlooked the "activesync" email. That and I'm used to seeing it labeled "Outlook Email".
While it's nice to know you can separate all the email accounts now, the problem remains that you still can't label these widgets.
there is a lot going on with widgets.
take a look here at home screens:
http://spbclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=24213&postdays=0&postorder=asc&...
and here at the general widgets forum:
http://www.spbclub.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=106
whats the RAM usage like on this?
I have been using Version 3 for a few days. Its ok but I want to go back to version 2. Is there an easy way to do that??
I am leary of trying this app. I have a Treo Pro from Sprint and Mobile Shell 2 destroyed my flash and IE 6 capabilities as well as messing with my phones C scripting abilities. Had to go back..
Is there any way do have the mobile operator name displayed like in Spb Shell 2.x? Or is noone missing it?
It's a pity it doesn't have tasks integration. I had to delete all my tasks and put them as RDVs to see them.
It's more fun than professional tool because the calendar tool is poor too.
I think they should make a professional version with better tasks and appointments integration and much more options (just 2 appointments? why?)
one day i went shopping outside ?and in an links of london store?I found some kinds of links of london i love most?they are: Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets Links of london mens bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets shopping Links of London Bracelets