Here we go again

Amazon reportedly buying Twitch for over $1 billion

Collections

Windows Phone Store Collections - Ninja Games

How To

Add your Google account to Windows Phone

General News

Google promises to fix Chrome bug on Windows, causing laptop batteries to drain

Windows Phone News

Microsoft preventing new Lumia owners from changing the default search engine to Google [update]

General News

Songza has just been acquired by Google

General News

Android tries to find visual identity through 'Material Design', borrowing from Microsoft

General News

Cortana will be fluent in Canadian in time for Windows Phone 8.1

General News

Songza curating multi-million dollar bid from Google

General News

Google blocks sideloading of Chrome extensions

General News

Google's YouTube rumored to be buying video game streamer Twitch for over $1 billion

General News

Outlook users can now join Hangouts with new Google plug-in

General News

Google offers incentives to bring XP business users to Chromebooks

General News

Microsoft gets decent clean energy marks from Greenpeace

Microsoft News

Microsoft announces Azure price cuts to combat Amazon and Google

Developers

Google releases official APIs for Windows Phone developers

Rumors

Asus reportedly not pairing Android with Windows due to pressure from Google

Editorials

You might love Bing and not even know it - a look behind the scenes

Editorials

Google's sale of Motorola may signal a stronger bond between Google and Samsung — and a threat to Windows Phone

General News

Google buys Nest, but a Windows Phone app is still possible

< >
6

WP7 Google Voice Clients – Review Roundup

The competition between Microsoft and Google has been raging for a number of years now. The Windows Phone and Android mobile platforms are only a small part, online services are where the real competition is raging. One of the services where Google has a clear lead is Google Voice.

If you haven’t signed up for the service, Google Voice has a number of helpful features. The basic idea is that you sign up for an account, choose a phone number, and then direct your phone traffic to this Google Voice Number. From there you can have the calls automatically forward to one or several other phone numbers. Google Voice also handles voice mail, emailing or texting you notifications, even transcribing messages so that you can get an idea of the content of a message without ever dialing your phone.

Since Google Voice is a core service of a Microsoft competitor, we will most likely never see native integration into Windows Phone, but there are already a number of third party applications that allow you to use the service on your Windows Phone. To see how they rate, keep reading.

GV for Windows Phone

I’m going to be brutally honest. Don’t waste your time with GV right now. GV is missing the capability for push notifications, which is a key component of every other option. Also, there are a number of user interface mistakes, like login buttons that are placed so that they are hidden behind the keyboard. GV could be a player at some point, but it’s not right now.

$1.99 from the Marketplace (Zune link).

Free Talk

Each of the Google Voice clients in this review use the Metro UI as their basis; but Free Talk’s take on Metro is slightly different than the others, and it’s a good thing. Navigation between the different areas of the app is smooth and seamless. The different messages and missed calls are displayed with either the contact’s name, or the best guess on location, which is a nice feature. Push notifications can be enabled in the paid version, though currently there is no live tile capability.

Free or $2.99 from the Marketplace (Zune link).

GoVoice

Offering easily the most simplistic interface, GoVoice doesn’t offer some of the niceties that you get with the competition. There is definitely some value in the utilitarian view that GoVoice features, there’s no need to fumble between screens and the back button is rendered obsolete. Push notifications are included, and Live Tile integration has been added in the latest update.

$2.99 from the Marketplace (Zune link).

GVoice

The only Google Voice client that offer’s a Live Tile at the time of this writing, GVoice jumps into contention for the top spot on that fact alone. Unfortunately there are some inconsistencies in the UI that drive my slightly (more) insane. The main screen features a call button, which brings up your phone’s contact list. Unfortunately there is no dialer presented, to get to that you have to go back to the main screen and swipe through the panorama. Furthermore, instead of using the built in dialer control, the makers of GVoice felt the need to build the dialer themselves. Small points perhaps, but these applications all offer extremely similar functionality, the small points are where comparisons must be made.

$3.99 from the Marketplace (Zune link).

Conclusion

For my money, GoVoice is the superior product of the bunch; though Free Talk is a close second. The clean and consistent UI, paired with the standard feature set and the Live Tile is enough to push GoVoice over the top.

Each of these applications feature a trial version, so take advantage of that to test the interface elements. I found that the UI is where the apps diverge, and your tastes may be wildly different than mine.

How much of a Google Voice user are you? Which app are you using to manage your account? Talk it up in the comments.

 

0
loading...
0
loading...
0
loading...
0
loading...

Reader comments

WP7 Google Voice Clients – Review Roundup

6 Comments

I've tried all of these apps and they all feel primitive and diverge from several proper Metro UI conventions. That being said, I've been running the trials of all of these apps and I can find a major reason not to use each one of them; so it leaves me using the website at voice.google.com in Mobile IE and dialing into Google Voice for voicemails. I don't understand why the live tile notifications have to look so ugly, like GoVoice's. Originally it looked like this: http://www.wpcentral.com/govoice-2-0-hits-brings-better-push-notificatio... but the creator has changed it in the latest version to be even bigger and uglier. What I'd rather see than all these apps is somebody integrate Google Voice voicemail and SMS functionality into a hub or into the existing People and Messaging hubs already in Windows Phone 7. Other apps have integrated into the Pictures and Music + Video hubs; why are developers so averse to adding functionality to the communication-oriented hubs?

First of all, you think making the notifcations GoVoice on the live tile made it uglier? I guess we're all entitled to our own opinion, but completely disagree with you. Having a larger identifier that "hey you have a message" is much better than having the tiny little one that was in the older version. I would know, i've had GoVoice since it launched. And are you familiar with development? Because as far as i know, and from what the developer has even said himself, some of the things that you're asking for aren't available as far as APIs, so NO APPPLICATION can do it. You can't integrate yourself into the people hub, or into any other part of the phone. For instance, you can't write in your code "when user presses a phone number to redial a number, rather than dialing the number, launch GoVoice, and dial the number though there" or, "when user hits a contact on the people hub, and chooses to send a message, use a this app instead. I have not seen a single third party app that's able to launch from outside the phone (other than responding to a toast notification), i think you're very wrong on that.

I'm using govoice; i see in your screenshots that instead of numbers you have the person's name, possibly taken from your phonebook? mine just has the number, am I missing a trick?

In the reviews, nothing was mentioned about any of the Google Voice apps offering a call back feature like GV Callback which is an android app.For users outside US, this is imperative. Standard Google Voice apps place the call via another number somewhere in US, for users in Canada, we incur long distance charges.With my Galaxy S, it works so well, can toggle on and off, no such luck with Windows Phone 7.I know Windows 7 Phone has a great future, I hope I am missing something and one of the existing apps supports call back.